Can You Lie to Save a Life? Rethinking Biblical Truthfulness (Tom Lutz) Ep. #279

Dr. Thomas Lutz

Episode Summary

Is lying ever justified? Does the Ninth Commandment require absolute honesty, even when telling the truth could cost someone their life? And what does biblical truthfulness mean for Christian leadership today?

In this episode of The Biblical Mind, host Mike Tolliver welcomes Dr. Tom Lutz, former pastor, business executive, and Christian leadership mentor, to explore the Ninth Commandment and its implications for ethics, business, and everyday life.

Drawing on biblical examples including Rahab, Moses, Rehoboam, and King Josiah, Lutz examines how Scripture distinguishes truthfulness from deception and why context matters when applying God’s commandments. Together, they wrestle with challenging ethical dilemmas, from hiding Jews during the Holocaust to misleading donors about a nonprofit’s financial health.

Lutz also explains why Christian leaders must cultivate a culture of truthfulness, welcome honest criticism, and resist organizational environments that reward deception. His approach emphasizes biblical wisdom as the practical application of God’s law rather than rigid rule-following or outcomes-driven ethics.

The conversation concludes with insights from Lutz’s book, Equipping Christians for Kingdom Obedience, exploring how the Ten Commandments can guide ethical decision-making, faithful discipleship, and leadership that helps individuals fulfill their God-given callings in the world.

Buy Dr. Lutz’s books here:
Equipping Christians for Kingdom Obedience: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0GTMXVKVP?lv=shuf&channelId=500&plpRedirect=mhFallback
Equipping Christians for Kingdom Purpose in Their Work: https://www.amazon.com/Equipping-Christians-Kingdom-Purpose-Their/dp/1683073991/?th=1

We are listener supported. Give to the cause here: https://hebraicthought.org/give

For more articles: https://thebiblicalmind.org/

Social Links:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/HebraicThought
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/hebraicthought
Threads: https://www.threads.net/hebraicthought
X: https://www.twitter.com/HebraicThough
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/hebraicthought.org

Chapters

00:00 The Nazi-at-the-door dilemma and the Ninth Commandment
02:12 From Baltimore pastor to business leader
05:13 The Decalogue as practical guidance for daily life
08:07 Applying biblical principles to modern responsibilities
09:05 How information gets distorted on its way to the CEO
13:20 Rehoboam rejects counsel, while Moses listens to Jethro
16:12 How Josiah responded when the law was rediscovered
20:55 Rahab, Samuel, and the limits of truth-telling
24:14 Concealment, context, and who has a right to the truth
27:28 What leaders should share – and where they can speak candidly
28:24 Why nonprofit fundraising must be truthful
31:00 Principles over outcomes, and the meaning of generosity
32:28 Lying prophets, judgment, and intent
35:14 Repentance, forgiveness, and biblical warnings about liars
36:38 Equipping Christians for Kingdom Obedience
40:27 The law as a guide for a redeemed people
42:05 Discipling people according to their calling

Transcripts are AI generated and are not guaranteed to correctly reflect the content of the podcast.

Mike Tolliver (00:00)
Does the ninth commandment, thou shalt not bear false witness, require you to tell the truth to the Nazi at your front door? You’ve probably heard that thought experiment. You know, a Nazi comes around, they’re looking uh to round up Jews and kill them. You’re harboring Jews in your home. So when the Nazi comes and knocks at the front door, they ask you, Are you harboring Jews? Do you answer truthfully? Of course, if you answer truthfully, they’re going to die. So you’re

Tempted to then violate the principle of truthfulness and lie to the to the Nazi. Now, while this question tends to tie ethicists up in a knot, um, in my interview with Dr. Tom Lutz, he makes short work of it, uh, citing numerous examples from scripture that help give guidance to those thorny issues, but then he also skillfully applies it to the contemporary context of uh

leaders in businesses uh creating a culture of truthfulness and how that impacts those around them. my brain is still cooking on the things that we talked about. So I’m certain that you will find some nuggets to take away into various contexts, whether it’s your sports team or the family or your business. um But if you like what we do here, go ahead and like us.

Share us, leave us a five-star review, uh, just a five-star review. If it’s four and a half or less, um, actually, for some reason, the systems out there don’t take that. It’s only five stars. Um, and if you’d like to partner with us, you can of course head over to uh thebiblicalmind.org slash give, uh, become a recurring donor. You can uh get the free book that we send out every year.

this particular year’s book is going to be a collection of essays that we got from the Bible First Conference on politics, which is pretty timely. So uh anyway, thank you always for supporting us in the many ways that you do. But uh that’s enough from me now. Let’s head on to the show.

Tom Lutz (02:12)
you know what I I’m asked that question. I always tell people I’m a little bit of an odd bird because I I I’m bilingual. I speak pastor and I speak business guy. And that’s a little bit unusual. Uh I was

Mike Tolliver (02:25)
Yeah.

Tom Lutz (02:25)
a pastor uh years ago uh in the PCA church in the inner city of Baltimore. and while that church was starting,

uh I I became involved in a startup business. Ultimately, after about seven years of being bivocational, uh, I really felt God’s call for me was into the business. and so ended up leaving uh the the church, although church continued to thrive and it’s still there to this day. But that kind of describes uh a bit of where I come from is is I’ve I was a pastor. Uh the business

grew to 1800 employees in 18 countries, so it was a fairly substantial business. and now, you know, we sold that business in 2000. Since then I do really three things. One is I I I facilitate Christian CEO roundtables. Um uh I uh uh teach at Metro Lana Seminary and then I do a fairly good bit of speaking.

Mike Tolliver (03:29)
Okay. Um, and I think you mentioned you’re you’re with Convene. You’ve been doing that for how long?

Tom Lutz (03:36)
Yeah, six

we have my sixteenth anniversary in May. it’s it’s convene is a um it’s about eighty groups around the country, and they’re basically uh Christian CEO round table groups, which meet together uh with the purpose of uh helping each other uh run exceptional businesses and kind of be high impact leaders to honor the Lord.

Mike Tolliver (04:04)
Okay. I I have a lot of questions for you that I I think we we we either need to have you back for a second uh conversation or all right, that that’s it. That’s it. Um

Tom Lutz (04:13)
I’m not coming back, sorry. No, I’d I I’m always happy to come back.

Mike Tolliver (04:19)
but the the main reason that we reached out was because you actually you wrote an article for

Tom Lutz (04:24)
Mm.

Mike Tolliver (04:25)
us that is gonna be coming out uh here I think in the next month. we’ll we’ll finally

Tom Lutz (04:29)
awesome. Okay.

Mike Tolliver (04:30)
have that edited and ready to go. But

um

It was it was a phenomenal article. And when we saw it, we thought, oh, we really gotta have him on the on the podcast to talk through this. So you really focused in on um y you’ve m talked, I think before about the the decalog, um, but specifically the the ninth commandment you focused on and its applications

Tom Lutz (04:53)
Mm-hmm, correct. Yep.

Mike Tolliver (04:56)
in leadership. And I’m I’m curious to hear you, you know, kind of unpack that. I d I know before I saw your article.

I didn’t immediately think of the C suite with respect to the Ninth Commandment. But as

Tom Lutz (05:08)
Mm-hmm.

Mike Tolliver (05:09)
I read your article, it became clear. So unpack that for me.

Tom Lutz (05:12)
Yeah.

Well, it comes from 16 years of working, you know, of course, having run my own business, uh, and then sixteen years of facilitating Christian business owners. Uh maybe give me a minute to give you a bit of context about the way I I see the Decalogue. Um, so I I I use a phrase that wisdom is the settled application of God’s law to daily life. When I teach wisdom literature, for example. And the idea there is.

Um the the the law is not some vague up in the sky sort of thing. It’s very practical culture building. Um and so what I’ve learned because I’m interacting, thinking about that in the context of facilitating CEO running their businesses. Um so I I tend to think about it loosely in this with this framework, is there’s the 10 words.

The Decalogue, the only time God spoke publicly to a multitude. And I think that’s a significant. Only once uh did God speak publicly to a multitude of people, and he spoke the ten words. I think then that becomes distinguished, you know, because the rest of the Exodus, it it it um in Leviticus, Numbers, Deuteronomy, it kind of distinguishes what God spoke, and it’s those ten words, and then Moses spoke.

Right. So there’s somehow a subtle distinction. So what I’ve come to how I’ve come to think about it is the decalogue is the ten unalterable absolutes, which then become the basis upon which decisions can be made in the world. Um and so and those decisions tend to be fall in the category of civil and ceremonial. Right. So they’re going to be the laws. How how do I go about well, take the case in point? No

Don’t bear false witness. Right? Um, and then you if you go through, there’s a distinction, it’s a technical term, but it I think it’s important between apodictic law and casuistic law. So when you

Mike Tolliver (07:24)
Sure.

Tom Lutz (07:24)
think about the constitution, constitution is apodictic law. It’s unalterable, it’s to to be applied in any and every circumstance. The particular application, the particular piece of legislation.

Would be um casuistic. It’s applying the higher principles to specific examples. So one that actually Dru used in his book uh was in Deuteronomy, we’re required to have a fence uh around our roof. And I will bet you don’t have a fence around your roof,

Mike Tolliver (08:00)
I do not.

Tom Lutz (08:01)
which makes you a lawbreaker. but uh

Mike Tolliver (08:04)
It does.

Tom Lutz (08:05)
but if you if you um

If you belong to a pool club or have a pool in your backyard, we have a fence around it. Same principle, same application going back to thou shalt not kill. Thou shalt not kill doesn’t mean just don’t take the life of. It means ah be responsible for the flourishing of all the lives entrusted to your care.

anyway, so that’s kind of the framework that I I tend to to think about. And so when I think in terms of the uh Ninth Commandment, I don’t think just in terms of Tom Lutz don’t lie, right? I think how does how is that Ninth Commandment to be played out in our culture? Um and what I’ve seen over the years, and by the way, the article I wrote because Drew kind of challenged me to talk about the Decalogue as it applies to the business.

world. uh the you know what is it what does it mean to build a culture of truth? So I’ve seen this happen more than one time in my own organization, uh, but also in um the organization of CEOs that I work with, where you’ll have, so I’m CEO, and then I have maybe a COO or sales manager or marketing manager.

And that person is skilled at what we call managing up. They they know how to make themselves look good to me,

Mike Tolliver (09:41)
Sure.

Tom Lutz (09:42)
right? But they’re not very good at managing down. And if if what I’ve seen happen on more than one occasion is that individual who I think is really good, uh, is actually intimidating people and not allowing information to get through them to me.

And the cul the consequence is we have a culture of deception, or or at least it’s not a culture of truthfulness. one of my first college courses I ever took, sociology course, and I don’t I I need to go search where this phrase came from, but they call it the iron rule of oligarchy. The fa you know, so truth on the shop floor is A. Then it gets told to the supervisor of the shop floor, and it gets

modified. And then the that person tells the regional manager. Regional manager tells the VP, the VP tells the CEO. By the time it gets up to the CEO, if you haven’t created a culture of truth, uh you’re not getting true information. Consequently, you’re making decisions based on false information. And obviously those are not going to be good decisions. So anyway, that

Mike Tolliver (11:00)
Yeah.

Tom Lutz (11:01)
was that’s so as

When when I read through, you know, I I’m always looking for what are the casuistic applications that are made in the Hebrew Bible. Um, and then how might they be uh how how might they, you know, the fence around the roof versus the fence around the pool? Same principle, uh, different illustration. Um, and so go ahead. Yeah.

Mike Tolliver (11:24)
Right. So I I like that move that you’re making.

And it i if I could just like name it because it I think it’s

Tom Lutz (11:31)
Okay.

Mike Tolliver (11:32)
super helpful, um, the the fence around the roof or the fence around the pool, that that it would be easy to dismiss the fence around the roof as oh, that is a civil law, it pertained to life in ancient Israel, we don’t have to look at that. But what you’re saying is that operating within that specific case that is presented.

in scripture is a principle that can be applied in any circumstance. And that principle in that case is the care for the the lives and livelihood of those around us. Um I think of

Tom Lutz (12:06)
Yeah. Mm-hmm.

Mike Tolliver (12:07)
the same thing I I always point to the ox gorer um as as sort

Tom Lutz (12:10)
Yeah, same idea.

Mike Tolliver (12:12)
of like a uh like prototypical uh workers comp um law and and you can then instantly

Tom Lutz (12:16)
Mm-hmm. Sure.

Mike Tolliver (12:19)
say oh yeah I may not have an ox but I might have a company vehicle.

Tom Lutz (12:23)
Mm-hmm. Yeah.

Mike Tolliver (12:24)
Um, and yeah, sure enough,

I’m responsible for what happens behind the wheel. Okay. So

Tom Lutz (12:28)
Yeah, also manslaughter

laws would be similar. You know, where you’ve done something irresponsible that has caused damage to another, you’re held responsible.

Mike Tolliver (12:38)
Absolutely. Absolutely. And so that um yeah.

Tom Lutz (12:40)
Yeah, so you get the picture. Dip same

same ultimate absolute principle that is applied differently given, you know, there are no rules about behavior on airplanes in the Hebrew Bible.

Mike Tolliver (12:54)
Mm-hmm.

Tom Lutz (12:54)
Right? But you gotta figure out how do I apply those rules when I’m on an airplane.

Mike Tolliver (13:01)
Okay. And so then you’re doing this with the Ninth Commandment in the corporate setting. Um, where where do you see maybe the Ninth Commandment teased out throughout the Hebrew Bible in unique ways that apply there?

Tom Lutz (13:20)
Yeah. Um, probably, you know, I think one of the most blatant would be when Rehoboam is taking over the kingdom from Solomon. And Rehoboam, uh so the the tr the ten northern tribes are basically coming to him and saying, We will not have you as king unless you change some of the onerous rules that your father put upon us.

And he goes to the older, wiser counselors, and their advice is don’t yeah, we’ll we’ll we should do that. We should back off on the taxation and the forced labor and these other things. Um, then he does what I think I call in the article uh opinion shops. So he he goes to his drinking buddies, who are going to be his counselors now, and asks them, and in the hubris of youth, they say,

Forget it. We’re gonna we’re gonna make it double down. We’re gonna be worse than ever. So what’s happened is uh he had an opportunity uh to hear truth, but he built an organization where people would tell him what he wanted to hear. Right. And and you can see how that that applies in just the example of the businesses that I’ve obvious the example that I’ve given about the way truth flows through an organization. Um

There’s a couple of other interesting ones. Moses ah in Exodus 18, his father-in-law, as father-in-laws are wont to do, came to him and Moses said, Moses, what you’re doing, what you’re doing is not good. ah Because he was he was not uh he would have thousand people in front of him, one after another, coming to get the same advice, essentially. And

Mike Tolliver (15:10)
Sure.

Tom Lutz (15:10)
Jethro says, What you’re doing is not good. You will be worn out, and the people will not be satisfied.

so what Jethro says, what you ought to do is organize Israel into thousands, hundreds, fifties, and tens. Then you train the thousands, the heads of the thousands, they’ll train the heads of the hundreds, they’ll train the heads of the of the fifties, and they’ll train the heads of the tens. So basically you’ve got a situation. what’s you what’s interesting about that is Moses.

says what Jethro says is good. I’m going to I’m going to act on it. So there’s a case where uh he was open to truth. Uh the people saw that he was open to truth. And so when he made this change, um the people understood that he had been uh advised, criticized possibly. ah And so he began to build a culture of of truth.

within his organization. Interestingly enough, when you go see the feeding of the 5,000 and the feeding of the 4,000, the people sat down in groups of 50. So you

Mike Tolliver (16:20)
Okay.

Tom Lutz (16:21)
want you’ll wonder if that, you know, that hadn’t come from uh ah hadn’t come from Jethro’s advice to to organize Israel into um groups like that.

Mike Tolliver (16:33)
And here we have the prophet like Moses uh heeding Jethro’s advice uh even then. That’s good. Um

Tom Lutz (16:38)
Precisely. Precisely.

Mike Tolliver (16:40)
okay, so I mean that’s helpful. Those two narratives work well almost as a foil of

Tom Lutz (16:46)
Mm.

Mike Tolliver (16:46)
what happens with the um, you know, c kind of culture of truth uh that you may or may not build. Um those examples rely on the uh leader.

to act on good counsel that is provided. So I’m curious,

Tom Lutz (17:07)
Okay, yep. Mm-hmm.

Mike Tolliver (17:10)
you know, are there any examples maybe of the leader receiving just sort of uniformly bad uh counsel and making a faithful decision um uh or, you know, something else that would give us a new nuance on that.

Tom Lutz (17:25)
well the one I uh mentioned about uh I think Moses, that that story with Moses is is is that example. I think Rehoboam is the opposite story of that. Excuse me. Um uh rephrase that question for me. I want to make sure I’m got my mind thinking in the right direction.

Mike Tolliver (17:49)
Sure. And so um, you know, I’m thinking of uh perhaps

Let me see. What what what how do I want to phrase this? So um you have the

Tom Lutz (17:59)
Yeah, okay.

Mike Tolliver (18:01)
the case of the leader who has the opportunity to act on good counsel. Both Moses and Jeroboam do uh have that opportunity or Rehoboam pardon me, have that opportunity,

Tom Lutz (18:13)
Ribbon, correct.

Mike Tolliver (18:15)
but Rehoboam then chooses to listen to bad counsel. Are there examples of uh you know uh a climate

Where the leader has been presented with only bad options, but chooses maybe to listen to the voice of scripture over and against those.

Tom Lutz (18:35)
That’s interesting. I would think probably uh Josiah, when the law was found, right, he had um which always blows my mind is what exactly does that mean? You

Mike Tolliver (18:46)
Yeah.

Tom Lutz (18:47)
know, did they were still doing the sacrifices, but they were just you know making it up? I don’t know. Um

Mike Tolliver (18:52)
Sure.

Tom Lutz (18:53)
but when it was found, he realized what he had. and then even though all the all of whatever the

Bad cultural traditions had been layered upon the cult at that point. he he went through, and one of the things, of course, it says uh is the king is supposed to uh write out his own copy of the Torah and to read it daily. Um and so I think there’s a good example of someone who had been given uniform bad advice, uh, and then as it turns out.

when he found out that he had been getting bad advice, uh, he made the cultural changes that were necessary to conform to the the law that had been found.

Mike Tolliver (19:40)
Yeah, and I I think that answer helped actually crystallize the question that I was looking for, which which is just

Tom Lutz (19:45)
good. Good, good.

Mike Tolliver (19:47)
how does that leader then um you know flip a culture that is maybe not rewarding of of truthfulness or uh obedience to the the ninth commandment in that way. So yes, that that is uh essentially where I was going with that. Okay. So that that’s helpful

Tom Lutz (20:02)
Yeah, good.

Mike Tolliver (20:03)
then. Um and as you see it then, the

The Ninth Commandment in in these many different faceted ways is like a a guiding star for leadership contexts. Um I’m curious.

Tom Lutz (20:19)
Yeah. amongst

you know, that particular is where my focus is with CEOs, but it obviously applies the way a church is run, the way a family is run, the way a baseball team is run.

Mike Tolliver (20:31)
Sure. Yeah, no, I uh appreciate that caveat. Uh that

Tom Lutz (20:33)
Right. Yeah, yeah.

Mike Tolliver (20:36)
there are many spheres in which a truthful uh um environment is g yes, yes.

Tom Lutz (20:40)
most spheres. Yeah. Th I

don’t think there are any spheres in which a a non truthful environment is a good situation.

Mike Tolliver (20:47)
Well, I may have one for you, and this is where I was going. All

Tom Lutz (20:49)
okay. All right.

Mike Tolliver (20:51)
right. So Rahab.

Tom Lutz (20:54)
Okay.

Mike Tolliver (20:55)
All right, let’s think think for a second here. Um, what what ends

Tom Lutz (20:57)
Sure, sure, sure.

Mike Tolliver (20:58)
up happening is there is an environment where a truthful answer leads to the death of the spies who she is

Tom Lutz (21:06)
Mm-hmm.

Mike Tolliver (21:07)
actively sheltering. She chooses to lie, saving the lives of the spies. And and then what’s more is she asks them to make a vow, which I would argue that

you know, the vowel system is also in some way, shape, or form connected to the ninth commandment uh application of the principle. So

Tom Lutz (21:27)
yeah. Well actually when Jesus talks

about it in in the Sermon on the Mount, he ties it to that. That’s his application of

Mike Tolliver (21:32)
Yes, right. Right, right, right. So,

you know, here you have Rahab in some way affirming the Ninth Commandment and yet violating it to

Tom Lutz (21:42)
Mm.

Mike Tolliver (21:42)
then care for others. You know, so it’s sort of this tension between the care for others and the ninth commandment in that example of Rahab. And uh first I’m curious to hear your take on that narrative, and then I’ll have a follow-up question for you.

Tom Lutz (21:57)
Mm-hmm. Yeah.

So um I think it was John Murray ah in his book Principles of Conduct who laid out some interesting distinctions. um If I’m remembering correctly, there’s a similar situation when Samuel was told by God to go um to anoint David or anoint the son of Jesse.

Not knowing which one he was going to anoint, he was told to go. And he says to God, Yeah, but if Saul finds out, I’m toast. Right?

Mike Tolliver (22:35)
Sure.

Tom Lutz (22:35)
And then the Lord says to him, uh, tell them you’re coming to sacrifice.

Interesting. So I think I think I maybe I don’t want to quote John Murray because it’s been a while, but I think the principle is something to this effect. Um some people have forfeited, or by the evident use that they make of truth, the right to have the truth.

Mike Tolliver (23:07)
Okay.

Tom Lutz (23:08)
So example, the Nazi knocks at your door,

Mike Tolliver (23:12)
Absolutely. Yeah.

Tom Lutz (23:13)
right?

And he walks in and he says, Do you have Jews in this house? Well, yes, I do. Uh, you know, you’re you’re you’re hiding them. Um I would think in that case, uh, it’s not lying, because uh truthfulness is made to those who have, because of the context, the circumstances, or whatever it might be, the right.

truth. Um so if you think about I’m a uh European football fan so and a US soccer fan and if you think about this is a maybe a silly example but it’s similar um Lionel Messi do you are you familiar with him enough to

Mike Tolliver (24:01)
yeah. yeah.

Tom Lutz (24:02)
yeah so so he’s he’s obviously at the end of his career he’s playing at at uh Miami uh

Mike Tolliver (24:09)
Which

is how you know he’s at the end of his career is ’cause he’s now in the MLS. Right. Yeah.

Tom Lutz (24:12)
Correct, ’cause ’cause he yeah, he’s a he’s

an emulator. He actually just retired. He said he’s played his last game with Argentina. But anyway, uh he deceives, right? He’s he’s a master of deception in the way he’s able to move that ball around. Um but but just by the n by the nature, by the the rules of football, uh the defensive player has forfeited

the right to not be deceived. So it’s

Mike Tolliver (24:43)
Okay.

Tom Lutz (24:44)
you similar so in other words, there are there are contexts. Um, you know, and I assume Samuel is thinking, if I go to if Saul finds out, I’m gonna be killed. Um and so there’s maybe it’s concealment might be the term that we would use for that. Um but if you look at you know Rahab of course is praised in um

uh in

Hebrews 11, uh as a is an as an image of the faithful prayer. Uh, there’s another case where Elisha, the Syrians come after Elisha, Elijah, I think it is. Syrians come after Elijah, and uh he bl they get blinded, and then he says, Uh, uh the one you seek is not in this city. I

Mike Tolliver (25:39)
Okay.

Tom Lutz (25:39)
will take you to where he is. Now,

If you think about that, it it was technically true because he was outside the wall. Right. but the the point was, if he said, you know, that’s me, well then the intent of the Assyrians would have been to kill him. And so it’s um I think it’s somewhere in that arena uh where we we need to determine whether or not you have the right to the truth, or if you will misuse the truth or abuse the truth if I told

seems to be where

Mike Tolliver (26:13)
Interesting.

Tom Lutz (26:14)
those kind of categories fall out.

Mike Tolliver (26:16)
So you you would uh look to the context to determine um the aspect of truthfulness as opposed to perhaps competing um imperatives, we’ll say, for lack of a better word.

Tom Lutz (26:32)
Yeah, I I’m not a fan of competing imper imperatives. Um, you know,

Mike Tolliver (26:36)
Okay.

Tom Lutz (26:37)
there are those who would take that position and say, well, Elisha lied, but God still liked him, Rahab lied, but um I I tend to think that it’s more a little more nuanced than that. Um and especially, you know, especially when you get in, you know, we’ll take it back to a business context. Do you know uh

Does the CEO need to walk up and down the halls and share every bit of bad news that’s going on? That’s one of the values of a group like Convene, where I get together in a room with 15 CEOs and they can they can say they can express the fears that are on their hearts that they really can’t express in the halls of the business. Right? So

Mike Tolliver (27:24)
Sure.

Tom Lutz (27:25)
there needs to be an outlet for that. Um

So yeah, I’m not sure we’re always required to tell all the truth all the time.

Mike Tolliver (27:36)
Sure. And

Tom Lutz (27:38)
Does that make sense?

Mike Tolliver (27:39)
yes, what it i essentially what you’re doing is you’re arguing for a very thick conception of what truthfulness entails, what it is and what it entails.

Tom Lutz (27:48)
Mm-hmm.

Mike Tolliver (27:49)
and I think that is a helpful direction to go. Um and

Tom Lutz (27:53)
Yeah.

Mike Tolliver (27:55)
as you’re talking, I’m even thinking of um, you know, Jesus being asked, Are you the king of the Jews? And he responds, You have said it is so. Um, you know,

Tom Lutz (28:02)
Yeah, I sent it. Yeah.

Mike Tolliver (28:04)
yeah, it it’s just um

you know, a different a different take on truthfulness that’s that’s helpful. Okay, so let’s well I I was about to take it in a

Tom Lutz (28:11)
Yeah, and again I think well go ahead, keep going. You’re on a roll.

Mike Tolliver (28:15)
slightly different direction because you got my my brain cooking here. What were you gonna say though? Okay. So

Tom Lutz (28:19)
Okay. No, you go. I’m gonna follow where you wanna go.

Mike Tolliver (28:24)
let’s let’s apply that view of truthfulness then to the um you know executive in a nonprofit who

maybe positions the financial um stability of the nonprofit to donors in a way that exceeds its current um financial stability, but that then encourages additional donations that achieve the financial stability that he or she is looking for. uh So

Tom Lutz (28:59)
Yeah, that’s good.

Mike Tolliver (29:00)
with that context of the you know charitable mission of the

nonprofit, if the the leader doesn’t get those donations, that evaporates. So in this instance, the context is sufficient to present the financials in a way that’s not currently the case or or what? Yeah.

Tom Lutz (29:23)
Truthful.

Yeah, no, I think well, if if the principle is uh ah I have to speak truth to those who have the right to the truth.

Mike Tolliver (29:35)
Okay.

Tom Lutz (29:35)
So if you’re the head of a nonprofit and you’re asking me to make a donation, uh I have the right to the truth about your financial situation. So, you know, it’s in other words, you can’t you can’t lie to um ah

Create a better ministry, if you will. Right. And that’s again, it’s there’s some of these things are are a bit subtle. Um, but yeah, I don’t, I that would not work for me. You know, in that

Mike Tolliver (30:10)
Okay.

Tom Lutz (30:11)
case, I think you have you have, or I have, in that scenario. I have the I have not forfeited the right to that truth by my choices or my behavior. I’ve

Mike Tolliver (30:21)
So it’s not

an sorry?

Tom Lutz (30:24)
Well, I just want to say an additional thing, it’s it’s not in your interest. Because if if if you deceive me into giving you money, right, by some even mildly deceptive practices, you’re creating an organization that’s not truthful, and your organization will not actually produce the value because you’re blinding it to the the need to.

to do better by taking in money that you don’t have a right, you don’t deserve.

Mike Tolliver (31:00)
Got it. Um, so I was just gonna synthesize kind of your approach here is it’s not an outcomes driven approach to truthfulness, it’s a principles approach to truthfulness. Um okay.

Tom Lutz (31:14)
That’s that’s a very good way to phrase it. Yeah. In other words, it’s

it’s and I think those principles then come from seeing the decisions that leaders make in Israel, you know, because that’s where the the um laboratory is. Uh you know, it’s a another example might be if we talk about thou shalt not steal. You know, if you look at the gleaning laws, you’re familiar with those, no doubt, were you not to take

I think the principle of the eighth commandment to me is um not everything that has been entrusted to your care is meant for your consumption. I think that’s what what the eighth commandment would mean. And so there’s a level at which um s you know it my fields are not a hundred percent for me. Part of my and that again, that’s principle-based. Um

Not that I don’t have fields. I suspect you don’t have fields. Um, but I have fungible cash, right? I have I can be generous in tips, uh, you know, that sort of thing.

Mike Tolliver (32:28)
So then, what do you make of God sending lying prophets to Israel?

Tom Lutz (32:38)
all right, let me think that one I haven’t thought a whole lot about. Uh

Mike Tolliver (32:43)
Okay.

Tom Lutz (32:44)
God’s yeah. you’re familiar with Isaiah ten, the story of the king of Assyria, where yeah it says uh King of Assyria uh he’s the rod of my anger, right? Uh but yet he’s punished. What’s the difference? He he is sent by God

To punish Israel. He goes and punishes Israel and then God punishes him. Uh the principle there seems to be, um

the the intent with which the king of Assyria did it was for his his own pompous aggrandizement. He was trying to make himself uh trying to benefit himself. So I would think maybe, I mean I I I can’t show you chapter and verse on this, but if that principle is correct in Isaiah 10, I think I think I’ve accurately stated it, uh God may s have sent the prophets

to do a task, but the prophets have done it uh in in a fashion that was not consistent with God’s intent.

Mike Tolliver (33:58)
Okay.

Tom Lutz (33:59)
They’ll work? I don’t know.

Mike Tolliver (34:00)
Well, yeah, I’m I’m just I’m sort of like testing at this um

Tom Lutz (34:05)
No, this is good. This is a this is fun.

Mike Tolliver (34:07)
this you know, uh conception of truthfulness from multiple different angles. And

Tom Lutz (34:11)
Mm-hmm.

Mike Tolliver (34:12)
you know, when you get what God does in the mix, it’s you know, it not that everything he does is something that we can do uh also, but it certainly does give

Tom Lutz (34:21)
Agree.

Mike Tolliver (34:23)
you know a different um a different light on uh truthfulness. And so um

That’s helpful. So let’s uh jump forward then to Revelation, was it 21, 218? Liars go to hell. Isn’t that um I had there there I I have in the back of my head f a friend who would sing that it to to song. so that’s all I’m hearing at the moment. Um

Tom Lutz (34:47)
Yeah. I I I think you’re right, yeah.

Mike Tolliver (34:50)
But uh you know that if there are different shades and different contexts to truthfulness.

Um are there different shades and different contexts to deceitfulness as well? Um some that might qualify as the liars that go to hell and some that don’t.

Tom Lutz (35:14)
Uh yes, interesting. I I would think the distinction there is not about the lie, but about the failure to repent. So Saul,

Mike Tolliver (35:26)
Sure.

Tom Lutz (35:27)
Saul is uh rejected by God uh because he failed to repent. I would argue that David was a lot worse person than Saul.

If you think about it, you know, at least what we have recorded, we don’t have any murders, rapes, or adultery, um, you know, etc., perpetrated by Saul, we do by David. What’s the difference? David, David was a man after God’s own heart, he repented. So I think the people that are going in, uh, if Revelation 21 is the correct passage, are going there because they have chosen not to repent.

Mike Tolliver (36:13)
Okay. So there’s a sense in which

Tom Lutz (36:14)
You know, I I’ve believe

it or not, I have lied. Believe it or not.

Mike Tolliver (36:19)
I I do believe it as it happens. Um

Tom Lutz (36:21)
I’m sure you do. Um,

but I’ve repented.

Mike Tolliver (36:24)
Yes.

Tom Lutz (36:24)
Right? And that’s the great advantage we have uh from a gracious God that He forgives.

Mike Tolliver (36:31)
So all all Cretans are liars. That’s the that’s Paul. There you go. Uh quoting a Cretan.

Tom Lutz (36:34)
Yeah, there you go. That’s a that’s Paul’s quote. Yep, absolutely.

Mike Tolliver (36:38)
Um got it. Okay. Well, so then um you had mentioned this as part of a broader project uh around the decalogue. Talk a little bit about that. I’m curious to learn.

Tom Lutz (36:48)
About the book? Yeah, so so the book is called Equipping Christians for Kingdom Obedience, a guide for disciplers. So my I consider myself a practical theologian. I teach at the seminary, I teach Bible, I could teach a Hebrew Greek, but I really I really feel like God’s call for me is the kind of discussions that we’re talking about. It’s it’s as a practical theologian.

I, you know, I use that term wisdom as the settled application of God’s law to daily life. and I I you know, here’s an interesting passage in um Deuteronomy chapter four, verse five and six. Um Moses is about in chapter five to repeat the Decalogue uh for the people as they’re entering the land, right? So that’s that’s the the nature of the book of Deuteronomy.

and he says to them, See, I have taught you decrees and laws, as the Lord my God commanded me. Be careful to obey them in the land you are entering to take possession of it. For this will show your wisdom in the sight of men when they see these statutes, will say, Surely this is a wise and an understanding people. And I think that’s akin to when Jesus says, Let your light so shine before men that they see your good deeds and glorify your Father ah in heaven.

you know, that so you know, when I think about that, wisdom is learning. Uh he does not so he meant there’s a distinction in the Hebrew, but Devrim, the Hebrew word for word, ten words, that’s where we get that expression, ten words. And then there’s Mishpat, mitzwa, hokma, all of which are applications. Right. And so anyway, um the the the um first book for me, uh ah when I first wrote it.

Um it’s on it’s kind of around the theology of work, right? What the Bible, what the Bible says about a person’s work. Um and I wrote it originally, went to some friends that I respected, uh, who had published other works, and uh all very politely they said to me, Tom, you’re not Tim Keller.

Uh very gently. These these are from but you know uh an environment of truth. Uh but but it it was um it the first book was published in the theology of work uh uh is the um Tyndale monograph. and it’s um

What they said was there’s a there’s a a need for a practical book on how do you teach that to someone that you’re discipling. And I said, Oh, that’s got my name on it. You know, that’s what I’ve done for certainly actively with CEOs, you know, in my younger days with with my employees. Uh anyway, so then so the basically in that book it says, Who are you? You’re an image bearer.

What’s your kingdom purpose? In other words, specifically, what is Mike Tolliver’s call in the mosaic of causing the world to flourish? And then how will you go about implementing your call? The uh equipping Christians for kingdom obedience is how do you teach them wisdom? If I’m right, wisdom is a settled application of God’s law to daily life. And so in that book, we I basically lay out four or five, six frameworks of how to read the law.

in such a fashion. You know, ’cause there’s

Dare I call it a meta-narrative? I don’t know your sphere, but you know, when I see students coming to the seminary, you know, there is a subliminal belief that the law was originally given that you could try to earn salvation as a result of it. And my contention is: no, it’s part of the covenant of grace, always was the covenant of grace, was given

Mike Tolliver (40:48)
Right.

Tom Lutz (40:49)
in the context of grace. It was always meant, as Moses indicated in chapter four of Deuteronomy, as

a way for them to think about what it looks like for a redeemed people to live in a new land. And

Mike Tolliver (41:04)
Yeah.

Tom Lutz (41:05)
he’s basically saying every every ethical decision that you’ll have to make, every cultural decision that you’ll have to make, uh, should be read through this lens of the of the decalogue.

Anyway, so that’s yeah, that’s the project. It’s just got that just got published in uh in April of this year. Yeah. So I’m excited about. Okay, awesome.

Mike Tolliver (41:27)
Okay. Okay. We I mean we can link to it in the show notes. I think that you know would be

of interest to a number of folks. So um well excellent. Well

Tom Lutz (41:36)
You know, I’m gonna

get I get rich when I sell books, so that’d be awesome. I could retire. Yeah, I could I could reti I don’t think I’m gonna retire on my earnings from that. but it’s

Mike Tolliver (41:40)
Yeah, right, right, right. Dru always makes that joke, is is like, Yeah, I could probably buy a cup of coffee.

Tom Lutz (41:48)
more uh I you know, I think God has given me a message. Um, and that message is uh to teach specifically people who are charged with discipling, uh, how rather than disciple people as church members.

Which is what I tend I think we’ve tended to be taught to do. Teach them to how how do you go about discipling them as image bearers? And that means, you know, I as a pastor, I as a seminary professor, I as a discipler, uh should not be teaching you how to do what I’m called to do. I should be finding out what you’re called to do and helping you get there. And I and I think so, but that’s really the that’s the big project.

Mike Tolliver (42:34)
Okay.

Tom Lutz (42:35)
you know, and both of the books fall in that category. They’re both oriented to you as a discipler rather than you as a disciple.

Mike Tolliver (42:44)
Got it. Well, Dr. Tom Lutz, thank you so much for your time and for your wisdom. I’m gonna be chewing on this for some time. Thank you.

Tom Lutz (42:54)
Well

good. Well it’s it’s not my wisdom, it’s God’s wisdom. Which He’s

Mike Tolliver (42:57)
Amen to that. All right.

Tom Lutz (42:59)
He’s generously given me a small bit of. No, it’s been fun, Mike. I really appreciate your time and this has been um now I know why I enjoy listening to the Biblical Mind podcast so much.

 

Share On:
  • Dr. Thomas Lutz

    Thomas P. Lutz, D.Min.
    Author, Seminary Professor, and Convene Chair 
    Thomas P. Lutz, D.Min., is an author, professor at Metro Atlanta Seminary, and Convene Chair who facilitates peer advisory groups for Christian CEOs and business owners. A former business executive, he has spent decades helping leaders connect biblical faith with their everyday work. He is coauthor of Equipping Christians for Kingdom Purpose in Their Work and author of Equipping Christians for Kingdom Obedience. He earned his Doctor of Ministry from Covenant Theological Seminary.

Most Recent Podcast Episodes

Podcast Featured Image Template (Yellow) Ep #273
Podcast Featured Image Template (Gray) 272
Podcast Featured Image Template (Brown) Ep #259
Podcast Featured Image Template (Green) Ep 264

Join the Mission to Bridge Faith and Understanding


Your support fuels research, teaching, and resources that shape minds and hearts. Invest in the future of Hebraic Thought.

Scroll to Top